Minors, like everyone else, have First Amendment rights. These rights extend to their ability to use social media both to speak and access the speech of others online. But these rights are under attac...
Read Full Article »EFF to Ninth Circuit: Young People Have a First Amendment Right to Use Social Media (and All of Its Features)
Discussion Points
- Balancing First Amendment Rights with Protection of Minors: Should online platforms be required to implement age verification measures and prohibit personalized recommendation systems for minors, or would this infringe upon their First Amendment rights?r
- The Impact of SB 976 on Social Media Platforms and Users: How will the law affect the user experience on social media platforms, particularly for minors, and what are the potential consequences for both users and platforms?r
- First Amendment Protections for Minors Online: Is it possible to protect minors from online harm while still respecting their First Amendment rights, or would age verification measures be an overreach of government authority?
Summary
R The California law SB 976, which restricts personalized recommendation systems for minors, is being challenged by EFF and other organizations. The district court's ruling that these feeds are not expressive activity is seen as a flawed interpretation of the First Amendment.
EFF argues that these feeds inherently reflect human expression and creativity, and therefore should be protected. The Ninth Circuit has stayed the law's implementation, allowing for further consideration of the issues.
The case raises important questions about balancing protection of minors with respect for First Amendment rights and the potential impact on social media platforms and users.