Key Points

• The concept of "good" jank in games: Is it subjective, or can it be quantified? How do developers balance the need for realism with player frustration?r
• The impact of movement mechanics on gameplay: Can a game's movement system make or break its overall experience? Are some forms of jank more acceptable than others?r
• The role of nostalgia in shaping opinions on jank: Do players' preferences for certain types of jank reflect a genuine enjoyment of the game, or is it a nostalgic attachment to past experiences? Summary r The latest Eternal Strands update has reignited the debate surrounding what constitutes "good" jank. As players continue to grapple with the game's movement mechanics, questions arise about the nature of this aesthetic. Is certain types of jank objectively more frustrating or enjoyable? The discussion highlights the tension between developer intentions and player experience. While some may view certain jank as endearing, others see it as a hindrance. As the community weighs in, it's clear that the perception of what is "good" jank will remain contentious. The game's developers must navigate this delicate balance to maintain player satisfaction.