Elden Ring Is Definitely Not An RPG: A Kotaku Debate

Published by Kotaku on in Gaming
Tags: elden ring rpg gaming kotaku debate role-playing game immersive storytelling player agency strategic decision-making game categorization public perception gamer communities games media classification gaming industry evolution rpg definition gaming terminology
AI Analysis

A role-playing game (RPG) is typically characterized by immersive storytelling, player agency, and often, strategic decision-making. However, the term's application can be subjective, with varying interpretations across different industries and communities. The context in which a game is played, its narrative depth, and thematic resonance all contribute to whether it should be classified as an RPG. Moreover, public perception and community discussions around a game's categorization can significantly impact its reputation and appeal. As the medium continues to evolve, refining our understanding of what constitutes an RPG will become increasingly crucial for both creators and consumers.

Key Points

  • r 1. The Importance of Context: Is a game an RPG solely based on its mechanics or also takes into account the thematic and narrative aspects? Shouldn't the context in which the game is played be considered when making such a classification?r 2. RPG Definitions Vary Across Industries: Different communities, such as tabletop gaming or online forums, may have their own definitions of what constitutes an RPG. Can these definitions be universally applied, or do they reflect the unique perspectives of each group?r 3. Categorization and Community Perception: How do community perceptions and discussions around a game's classification affect its reputation and potential players? Should the definition of an RPG be influenced by public opinion or should it remain based on clear, objective criteria?

Original Article

What is a role-playing game? You probably have your own definition and exceptions. And as you might expect, nearly everyone at Kotaku has thoughts and opinions on what is and isn’t an RPG. For example, some think Elden Ring is an RPG. Others disagree strongly. And then some think the idea of categorizing games via…

Read more...

Source: Kotaku

Share This Article

Hashtags for Sharing

Related Articles

Comments